Security Basics mailing list archives
Re: Hard Drive data security (magnet link)
From: Kirk Schafer <infosec-capital () rainswept com>
Date: Mon, 18 Oct 2004 18:25:49 -0500
The company that provides the magnets responded. I didn't get info on the ceramics, but I believe they're still about $15 (+ shipping)--don't quote me. "Neo" refers to "neodymium". I have a small one--they are insanely potent magents.
Quote:"I have sold the rare earth magnets for disrupting information on discs, but we do not claim to remove info, only disrupt it enough so it is not readable.", and, "I have sold the larger neo blocks to hospitals and to governmental agencies for this application. But the neo magnets are expensive, the largest is a 1" X 2" X 2" NB147N-35 and they are $55.00 per."
I think the obvious caveat is that anytime you remove data this way, you might miss something, and recovery companies (albeit very expensive) still might succeed. But I'm just talking about good enough. With unprotected media, I was not able to recover anything after using a class 8 ceramic magnet...but hard drives, not so successful. Neo seems to be the way to go.
Kim's been a good rep, and here's the contact info: Kim DeLong - Industrial Sales Consultant Master Magnetics, Inc. 888-293-9399 ext 128 http://www.magnetsource.com Best, Kirk GuidoZ wrote:
Also in regards to:Try the non-techie approach....after they verify that your hard drive is bad...then take a hammer to the disk...pound on it a few dozen times...then give it to them. Why do they want your bad hard drive anyway?OEMs like Dell, Compaq, HP, etc want the bad parts to ensure they are bad. It also gives them a cusion they can use to keep some people from returning things for repair. (They intentionally take 2-4 weeks for a turnaround, plus make it a pain in the ass to do so. Saves them money in the long run.) Unfortunately the OEM could never verify that the drive is bad without having it in their posession and testing it for themsevles. I'll betcha using a hammer would void the warranty. ;) Another problem I've run into is trying to wipe a bad hard drive with any common software tools (I'm a big fan of Dban too.) If the hard drive has suffered from a head crash or other form of physical failure, it may not be able to perform a wipe. In this case, a strong magnet is the only solution you have left. Data can be recovered from a hard drive even if it fails physically. Granted it will only be by someone who REALLY wants the data off of it, but it's still quite possible. There are businesses dedicated to this aspect of data recovery. I've dealt with www.DriveSavers.com a number of times. They are quite good at recovering data from a hard drive regardless of it's state. (Fire, Damage, Virus, Head Crash, etc) Kirk Schafer <infosec-capital () rainswept com> mentioned what you'll need here:Given the nature of business, sometimes all you have to be is "good enough" to make someone look elsewhere. For media not protected by a metal shell (like a hard drive), a strong magnet will work. A permanent ceramic with sunspot strength can be obtained for about $15. A have one in my office, and a few swipes with one of these and data evaporates. If you're interested in this, I'll refer you to a good supplier.I'd take him up on his offer for information. ;) -- Peace. ~G On Thu, 14 Oct 2004 15:21:56 -0400, ssaehrig () jxray com <ssaehrig () jxray com> wrote:Paul, If you want a utility to completely erase a hard drive use dbnuke. It is a linux based utility and runs from a cd or floppy. The utility will perform a complete erase of the hard disk and is not recoverable if you do the highest security wipe. If you Google search it you will have no trouble finding the download. You have to burn it as an ISO image for a cd. The utility is free and very easy to use. ________________________________ -----Original Message----- From: D. Weiss [mailto:David () cawdgw net] Sent: Wednesday, October 13, 2004 6:11 PM To: 'tony tony'; 'Jonathan Loh'; 'Paul Kurczaba'; security-basics () securityfocus com Subject: RE: Hard Drive data security The only real way to destroy the data is either to sand the platters off or melt the whole thing down. Sanding is easier and if you use a nice fine grade sand paper as the last sanding, you can get the disks engraved for IT awards and whatnot. -----Original Message----- From: tony tony [mailto:tonytorri () yahoo com] Sent: Tuesday, October 12, 2004 12:43 AM To: Jonathan Loh; Paul Kurczaba; security-basics () securityfocus com Subject: Re: Hard Drive data security Paul, Try the non-techie approach....after they verify that your hard drive is bad...then take a hammer to the disk...pound on it a few dozen times...then give it to them. Why do they want your bad hard drive anyway? --- Jonathan Loh <kj6loh () yahoo com> wrote:Use eraser, or norton wipe, or some other tool to erase the whole thing. Eraser is a free utility. But note this only works if the company usesjustanother computer to try to recover your data. If they use scanning microscopy well then...... but that's expensive. That's if you can access the drive. If you can't powerful magnets work really well. Just make sure the harddrive is out of the computer when you dothat.--- Paul Kurczaba <paul () myipis com> wrote:Hi, I have a question about hard drive data security. The hard drive onmynotebook is failing and Dell is going to replace it. They are going totakethe old one with them. How can I securely remove the data from the hard drive? Thanks, Paul__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - 50x more storage than other providers! http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail===== Tony T. CISSP, CISA, CDP, CIA Senior IS Security & Risk Manager 360.906.7893 (Work) Northern Telecom LLP ______________________________________________________________________ This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email Security System. For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email ______________________________________________________________________
-- ___________________________________________________ Kirk Schafer Infosec Capital - Your Information Security Asset 308 East Broadway Ave, PO Box 1851 Fairfield, IA 52556 641-919-1783 (mobile) http://www.infosec-capital.com
Current thread:
- Re: Hard Drive data security, (continued)
- Re: Hard Drive data security tony tony (Oct 12)
- RE: Hard Drive data security David Gillett (Oct 13)
- RE: Hard Drive data security D. Weiss (Oct 14)
- Re: Hard Drive data security Kirk Schafer (Oct 15)
- Re: Hard Drive data security Ghaith Nasrawi (Oct 15)
- RE: Hard Drive data security ssaehrig (Oct 15)
- Re: Hard Drive data security GuidoZ (Oct 15)
- Re: Hard Drive data security GuidoZ (Oct 15)
- RE: Hard Drive data security Chris Carter (Oct 18)
- Re: Hard Drive data security (slightly OT) Kirk Schafer (Oct 19)
- Re: Hard Drive data security (magnet link) Kirk Schafer (Oct 19)
- Re: Hard Drive data security tony tony (Oct 12)