Re: fw-1 general & VPN questions

[Lyndon David <lyndond () sentinet co uk>]

Yes serial console lines on workstations are not very good. With regard to
the idea of running ppp over the serial console. On a sun box if you send a
break down the console line the box drops to the boot prom. I expect that
there are ways around this behavoir by changing the prom variables.

I thought that the point of the serial console line was that it was a last
resort communication mechanism because the box has become unresponsive from
across the network.

Lyndon

Marcus J. Ranum wrote:

> Joseph S. D. Yao wrote:
> > > I also intend to do some "out-of-band" mgmt with a dialin
> > > modem on the serial console of the two sun boxes (yes, yes,
> > > wardialers I know). However, this is what the customer wants,
> > > and I have no say-so, so I need to simply get it set up.
> >
> > Can you at least get them to use a dial-back modem?  Or even strong
> > authentication at the dial-in terminal server?
>
> Sounds like there's no terminal server there, just dialin on
> the serial console. :(
>
> Warning: workstations often have incredibly lame serial consoles.
> I don't know about the particular sun boxes you're planning to use
> but I've had $40,000 screaming hot workstations barely able to handle
> serial I/O at 38.8k.
>
> I've been pondering the secure remote management thing for a while
> and was trying to come up with decent solutions that are dirt cheap.
> Haven't tried this, but does anyone see a flaw with:
>   - have a log-in that drops you right into PPP using CHAP
>   - run ip_filt on the workstation to filter access via the PPP interface
>   - let only SSH in over PPP (or whatever other services are OK)
>
> mjr.
> --
> Marcus J. Ranum, CEO, Network Flight Recorder, Inc.
> work - http://www.nfr.net
> home - http://www.clark.net/pub/mjr