FW: BorderManager vs MS Proxy 2 and Firewall-1

["Joe Ippolito - President SVNPA" <joe () joesnet com>]

-----Original Message-----
From:   Joe Ippolito [SMTP:joe () joesnet com]
Sent:   Saturday, March 07, 1998 11:28 AM
To:     'Stephen Moore'
Subject:        RE: BorderManager vs MS Proxy 2 and Firewall-1

I have evaled both but am biased toward the MS product due to the ease of 
setup and reporting functionality.  Border Manager's plus is speed (state 
of the art web caching) and NDS integration.  Reporting capability and 
price are its minuses.  Got any specific questions let me know.

Also, if anyone has any experience with Check Point Firewall-1 on NT4, I 
would like to exchange some war stories.  Difficulties I am having are GP 
faults, connectivity issues -GUI client and remote module, file puts with 
CVP running etc. etc. etc.  Check Point will not give me access to their 
knowledge base and I need ammunition to persuade them to give me access.

Joe Ippolito MCNE, MCSE, CSA

-----Original Message-----
From:   Stephen Moore [SMTP:Stephen.Moore () student shu ac uk]
Sent:   Friday, March 06, 1998 8:36 AM
To:     firewall-wizards () nfr net
Subject:        BorderManager vs MS Proxy server 2

Hello All,
Can anyone help me?
My situation is that I am undergoing a study at University which
involves the above firewall products. I wish to know what categories I
can evaluate the products under and has there been a comparrison been
made before.
Many thanks
Steve Moore

Reply to the above address for urgency