Firewall Wizards mailing list archives

Re: future of IDS


From: Brent Huston <bhuston () netwalk com>
Date: Fri, 16 Oct 1998 16:02:21 -0400

Well, my opinion is that IDS will become imbedded in network switch
technology, or a common connection point will become available on the
switch to deploy IDS on.

Both situations have pros and cons, but I definatly see IDS becoming more
of a network appliance than current systems are today.

At 10:24 PM 10/14/98 , Colin Campbell wrote:
Hi,

(may show some ignorance here so be gentle :-)

Our firewall sits between two networks. The "external" houses lots of
internet-visible web servers, much as one would expect. The internal net
houses intranet servers. Up until recently, these nets were just plain old
hubs. They also suffered from consistent 10% collision rates. Everyone was
hurting.

Consequently, we replaced these hubs with switches. Network performance is
great. No collisions, the machines that can talk at 100Mb do, all is well
with the world. Well, almost. I tried snooping some traffic between two
machines and when I saw nothing, the difference between hubs and switches
suddenly dawned on me.

Now, after all this preamble, I do actually have a question for the great
minds to ponder. With the likelihood that more and more hubs are going to
disappear and be replaced by switches, where does that leave the humble
IDS that can no longer see all the traffic it needs to, to do its job?

Colin

---
Brent Huston                                    bhuston () microsolved com
President                                               614-351-1237
MicroSolved                                     Fax: 614-351-9015
Information Security Consulting, Penetration Testing, Auditing
Internet Security Systems, Secure Computing, Axent Reseller

http://www.microsolved.com



Current thread: