Re: Re: Case ID 51560370 - Notice ofClaimedInfringement

["Jason Coombs" <jasonc () science org>]

> The content inside is still fully usable
> and valid but a violation cannot be
> confirmed without yourself violating
> the law.

First of all, what law do you believe is violated by 'downloading' an unauthorized MP3 duplication of a recording?

Fair use doctrine covers this situation in a number of ways. For example, you do not violate copyright by downloading a 
file in order to find out what it is and where it came from, any more than you violate copyright by tuning into a radio 
broadcast. Somebody ELSE violates copyright if they broadcast a copyright-protected work, or distribute copies for 
download. You, as downloader, are fully within the fair use doctrine if you just receive, contemplate, and destroy upon 
recognizing that the work was not distributed by an authorized distributor/broadcaster.

How do you know what is and isn't authorized? Are you required to judge a book by its cover, even though the cover is 
nothing more than a filename in these cases? You are fully within the fair use doctrine if you download for the sole 
purpose of causing your computer to examine metadata that may allow you to determine the content, or if you contemplate 
the content with your senses by playback or access -- when and if you are satisfied that you have received a work that 
perhaps has not been duly licensed, you are in fact free to locate the copyright holder and negotiate a license.

Furthermore, in the get-a-clue department once again, the people who are doing the downloading to assist copyright 
holders with enforcement actions or investigations HAVE WRITTEN PERMISSION and therefore cannot be accused of violating 
the law by doing the download.

Why do people insist on spreading FUD when these are simple matters of intellectual property law and contract law that 
any person above the mental age of 14 has no trouble understanding when the facts are presented clearly?

Cheers,

Jason Coombs
jasonc () science org
_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/