nanog mailing list archives
Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch?
From: Joe Shaw <jshaw () insync net>
Date: Tue, 26 Aug 1997 02:15:04 -0500 (CDT)
On Mon, 25 Aug 1997, joseph j. kim wrote:
i don't understand all of the mail comparing the two, there is really no comparison. the GSR blows the GRF away.
I wasn't comparing the GSR and the GRF. I was comparing the Cisco 7508 that I used to have at a previous job to the GRF 400 I just got. As far as the GSR goes, I haven't seen one in real life. It sounds cool, but I want to see one for myself before I say the thing walks on water. My GRF works great now, and I'm satisfied with it's performance so far, though right now it's still not doing much.
there is an order of magnitude difference in the aggregate b/w supported between the two correct? 4Mb/s vs 40Mb/s.
From the Ascend Web Page:
Available in two sizes, the GRF 400 holds up to 4 media cards for up to 4 Gb/s bandwidth, while the GRF 1600 supports up to 16 media cards for up to 16 Gb/s of bandwidth. The unique GRF switching architecture is specially designed to handle network growth while providing consistent, high performance, regardless of the dynamics of the network. It has the following cards: Ascend ATM OC-3c IP Forwarding Media Card Ascend FDDI IP Forwarding Media Card Ascend HSSI IP Forwarding Media Card Ascend IP/SONET OC-3c IP Forwarding Media Card Ascend 10/100Base-T IP Forwarding Media Card For more details, check http://www.ascend.com/300.html.
From Cisco's:
technology preview of Cisco's new family of gigabit switch routers (GSRs) providing high performance solutions ranging from 5 to 60 Gb/s for Internet and large-scale WAN Intranet backbone applications. Now, I've got a GRF 400 with the ATM OC-3c card, the FDDI card, and the 10/100Base-T card. It works flawlessly. And I can't honestly see how the
Also, not that I know anything about the GRF but I think Cisco claims that 7500 real-world performance is much better than the GRF400.
I've had cisco sales reps claim even more ludicrous things while the support engineer started turning red, so who knows... Comparing GateD to IOS becomes more of a religious preference than anything else. I'm content knowing both, truth be told.
maybe someone can post some performance numbers. -jjk
Joe Shaw - jshaw () insync net NetAdmin - Insync Internet Services
Current thread:
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch?, (continued)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Neil J. McRae (Aug 26)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Brian Horvitz (Aug 22)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Nathan Stratton (Aug 25)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Gary Zimmerman (Aug 25)
- RE: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Chris MacFarlane (Aug 25)
- RE: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? nanog mail reader (Aug 25)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Mike Gaddis (Aug 25)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? David Mercer (Aug 25)
- RE: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? nanog mail reader (Aug 25)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? joseph j. kim (Aug 25)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Christofer Hoff (Aug 25)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Joe Shaw (Aug 26)
- perf #s for GRF vs 7500 Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? joseph j. kim (Aug 26)
- Re: perf #s for GRF vs 7500 Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Craig A. Huegen (Aug 26)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Neil J. McRae (Aug 26)
- Re: Anyone Deployed Ascend's GRF IP Switch? Nathan Stratton (Aug 26)