nanog mailing list archives
Re: Well done Sprint!
From: Network Operations Center <noc () nwrain net>
Date: Thu, 13 Nov 1997 18:15:56 -0800 (PST)
Hello alex, On Thu, 13 Nov 1997, Ex-Support Wench wrote:
What do y'all think of pathchar *as it is now*? How reliable is it for determining actual _available bandwidth_? I thought according to VJ, CAIDA, Cisco and even the NSF it was "way-alpha"?
From the testing I've done the results are a reasonable approx. of the -available- bandwitdh. I have also seen some very outragious output out of the utility (solaris). The linux version isn't able to figure out the MTU so you have to specify it on the command line, when traversing a slower link the out put from the far side can be -very- un-reliable. Hth, JimL
Steve Blair wrote:well, one could get Van Jacobson's pathchar, and learn the true capacity that way. I could care less what *theoretical bandwidth* is available, when customers complain. I want to know what bandwidth *is available*, and pathchar goes a very long way towards that end. link labelling could be arguably silly, if you're basing your determination on a competetitor's labels, you could get some unusual surprises IMHO... -- steve c blair tivoli systems inc sblair () dev tivoli com "Why can't we blast them onto someone else's property?" 'Vadim Antonov writes...' **> **> There's no use in promoting corporate paranoia at the expense of **> engineering cooperation. It is like butcheing the hen which lays **> the golden eggs. Knowing link capacity was useful (while it lasted) **> to get the idea of what is more likely to be dropping packets **> on the floor when customers complained.
Current thread:
- Re: Well done Sprint!, (continued)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Bob Collie (Nov 12)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Josh Beck (Nov 14)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Scott Huddle (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Vadim Antonov (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Steve Blair (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Dorian R. Kim (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! SK Miller (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Vadim Antonov (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! cll (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Craig A. Huegen (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Network Operations Center (Nov 13)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Henry Kilmer (Nov 14)
- Re: Well done Sprint! Randy Bush (Nov 14)