nanog mailing list archives
RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS?
From: "Alex P. Rudnev" <alex () Relcom EU net>
Date: Tue, 18 May 1999 23:31:42 +0400 (MSD)
Because IP multicasts are broken as designed?
And because (I guess) Internet lost such thing as, I do not know exact name, fixed addresses for the fixed services: for example, 254.0.0.1 for DNS, 254.0.0.2 for mail relay, etc etc. First IP drafts seems to had such ideas, but then this ideas was lost, and that make media caching more difficult (through possible) task to realise.
In any case, L3 mcasting seems to be pretty much dead. Replicating
I better prefer to say _it's the train which is over already_. Existing network have a much of multimedia sources, and they don't use multicast. Now there is easy to add caching and autho-replication then to build parallel multicast network based on very complex and suspicious mechanisms. Through, multicast can feel itself well - in the end LANs. Alex. /sitting 10 meters next to the workstation where multicast is used for internet TV experiments/.
canned content is better done with caches, and conferencing requiries real MCUs which do things like speaker selection and noise suppression. Injection of end user-supplied routing information (JOIN/LEAVE requests) into the core backbones is not going to work in a real life, period. --vadim
Aleksei Roudnev, Network Operations Center, Relcom, Moscow (+7 095) 194-19-95 (Network Operations Center Hot Line),(+7 095) 230-41-41, N 13729 (pager) (+7 095) 196-72-12 (Support), (+7 095) 194-33-28 (Fax)
Current thread:
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS?, (continued)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Nick Bastin (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Gary E. Miller (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Vadim Antonov (May 17)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Vadim Antonov (May 17)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Pete Kruckenberg (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Vadim Antonov (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Hank Nussbacher (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? jprovo (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Alex P. Rudnev (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Vadim Antonov (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Alex P. Rudnev (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Vadim Antonov (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Vadim Antonov (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Alex P. Rudnev (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Vadim Antonov (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Steve Riley (MCS) (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Alex Bligh (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Randy Bush (May 18)
- RE: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Pete Kruckenberg (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Alan Hannan (May 18)
- Re: Is anyone actually USING IP QoS? Nick Bastin (May 19)