nanog mailing list archives
Cisco Misrepresents Results of First Independent Test of Core Routers
From: Robert Beverly <rbeverly () rbeverly net>
Date: Thu, 15 Mar 2001 08:57:34 -0500
Appologies if some of you have already seen this. Cisco reached some interesting conclusions from this test in their press release: http://biz.yahoo.com/bw/010314/0647.html stating that their 12416 performed the best. Lightreading issued a subsequent warning about the inaccuracies of Cisco's statement: http://www.bigcharts.com/news/articles.asp?newsid=776376576&symb=JNPR&sid=150116 rob
Readers of this list may be interested in the results of a four-vendor core router bakeoff just posted here: http://lightreading.com/testing Each vendor supplied: up to 12 x OC-192c up to 48 x OC-48c The entries were: Charlotte's Networks Aranea-1 Cisco 12416 Foundry NetIron Juniper M160 Tests included: IP baselines MPLS baselines BGP table capacity MPLS LSP capacity longest-match lookup route flapping route convergence filtering class of service There's also a discussion of packet reordering.
Current thread:
- Cisco Misrepresents Results of First Independent Test of Core Routers Robert Beverly (Mar 15)