nanog mailing list archives
Re: Stealth Blocking
From: Mitch Halmu <mitch () netside net>
Date: Wed, 23 May 2001 22:38:11 -0400 (EDT)
On Wed, 23 May 2001, Christopher B. Zydel wrote:
Like any other "law", the MAPS RBL has power only because the population (of ISPs in this case) at large believes that it is just, and should be followed. ISPs that subscribe to MAPS RBL are saying that they believe that open relays should not exist, that MAPS should be able to test for this condition, and that they don't want to receive e-mail from non-compliant hosts. If you think this is a bad "law", then you'll need to convince enough of the rest of the population at large of such, and then perhaps ISPs will unsubscribe from the MAPS RBL. /cbz
The problem with your logic is that ad-hoc 'laws' conceived by majorities do not necessarily reflect the actual law of the land. Our legal system has conceived checks and balances against the tyranny of the majority. There are compelling reasons throughout history why such system works best. A trivial example of my point are anti-discrimination laws. Unfortunately, technology jumped too far ahead, too fast. A lot of the issues discussed here will revert back to normality, just like in any aging frontier community, once the legal system catches up. Some may not want the government's camel in their tent, but I say it's preferable to the status quo and levels the playing field again for all players. --Mitch NetSide
Current thread:
- Re: Stealth Blocking, (continued)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Robert Sharp (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Valdis . Kletnieks (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Robert Sharp (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Valdis . Kletnieks (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Robert Sharp (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Margie Arbon (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Aaron L. Meehan (May 23)
- RE: Stealth Blocking Vivien M. (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Alex Bligh (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Christopher B. Zydel (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Mitch Halmu (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Jason Slagle (May 24)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Valdis . Kletnieks (May 24)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Jason Slagle (May 24)
- RE: Stealth Blocking Jeremiah Kristal (May 23)
- RE: Stealth Blocking Mitch Halmu (May 23)
- RE: Stealth Blocking John A. Tamplin (May 24)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Christopher A. Woodfield (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Albert Meyer (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Shawn McMahon (May 23)
- Re: Stealth Blocking Albert Meyer (May 23)