nanog mailing list archives
Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning))
From: "J.D. Falk" <jdfalk () cybernothing org>
Date: Sun, 27 May 2001 18:44:02 -0700
On 05/27/01, Mitch Halmu <mitch () netside net> wrote:
Is there a rule that, except for local dial-in, we cannot offer the same services to a client located in a part of the world that we dont't have a dial-in POP as we offer to our local clients? Why shouldn't such clients be able to get their dial-in somewhere and the rest of their services from somewhere else? That includes using a remote SMTP server in the same way a local user can, period.
You have to balance that desire against your users' generally unspoken requirement that your service be functioning, usable, and able to deliver mail to its' final destination. If this were any other kind of service that commonly requires user authentication (accounting, data storage, etc.) there wouldn't even be a question. And seriously, Mitch, when was the last time that you heard a new argument for why you should close your relay? Since you're obviously unwilling to do so, what's the point of bringing it up again and again? -- J.D. Falk SILENCE IS FOO! <jdfalk () cybernothing org>
Current thread:
- ORBS (Re: Scanning) E.B. Dreger (May 27)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Roeland Meyer (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) E.B. Dreger (May 27)
- Re: EMAIL != FTP Adam Rothschild (May 27)
- Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Steve Sobol (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Derek Balling (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Dan Hollis (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Mitch Halmu (May 27)
- Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) J.D. Falk (May 27)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Mitch Halmu (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Stephen J. Wilcox (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re:Scanning)) Steve Sobol (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Adam Rothschild (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Steve Sobol (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) J.D. Falk (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) up (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) John Fraizer (May 28)
- RE: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Vivien M. (May 28)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Stephen J. Wilcox (May 28)