nanog mailing list archives
Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement
From: Roland Perry <roland () linx net>
Date: Mon, 10 Mar 2003 14:09:52 +0000
In message <019c01c2e6e5$8dc23710$7c28a8c0 () cblan mblox com>, Peter Galbavy <peter.galbavy () knowtion net> writes
Policy was, many years ago, when we were 'all' at Demon that we would *never* hand out any logs until there was a court order. Period. At that point we would roll over and stick our paws in the air... subtle hints from the police and others were met with this policy.
Yes, the current situation in the UK is that there are (for hacking enquiries, but not financial matters) no police "powers" other than a court order, but many CSPs (voice telcos especially) are sympathetic to special pleading from the police that revealing information about their customers is justified if it's the only way progress a criminal investigation. http://www.linx.net/misc/dpa28-3form.html The recent issue with Scotland Yard might suggest that this pleading had been unsuccessful, but they didn't then go and get a court order (for whatever reason).
Of course, the RIP Act brings big brother truly to life now. If only the civil service would stop infighting long enough to implement it ;-)
It was the Minister (Blunkett) who stopped the implementation, due to police politics... For once, the civil servants were innocent. -- Roland Perry | tel: +44 20 7645 3505 | roland () linx org Director of Public Policy | fax: +44 20 7645 3529 | http://www.linx.net London Internet Exchange | mbl: +44 7909 68 0005 | /contact/roland
Current thread:
- UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Sean Donelan (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Dan Hollis (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement- COPA Enforcement BAN Richard Irving (Mar 07)
- RE: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Mark Borchers (Mar 07)
- RE: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Dan Hollis (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Peter Galbavy (Mar 10)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Roland Perry (Mar 10)
- RE: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Dan Hollis (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Steven M. Bellovin (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Neil J. McRae (Mar 08)