nanog mailing list archives
Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news)
From: Paul Vixie <vixie () vix com>
Date: 14 Oct 2005 20:48:55 +0000
david.conrad () nominum com (David Conrad) writes: (shouldn't that be drc () iana org now?)
If my impression is correct, then my feeling is that something else is required. I am somewhat skeptical that shim6 will be implemented in any near term timeframe and it will take a very long time for existing v6 stacks to be upgraded to support shim6. What I suspect will be required is real _site_ multihoming. Something that will take existing v6 customer sites and allow them to be multi-homed without modification to each and every v6 stack within the site.
if all you've got is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. so, the above problem statement looked like a dns issue to me, and to some other folks, and thus was born A6. had ietf killed AAAA back when there were effectively zero ipv6 hosts on the 'net, and paid the apparently-high A6 complexity penalty, we'd be talking about something else by now. as it is, the shim6 complexity penalty is even higher, and i don't think we'll ever get to stop talking about this problem. -- Paul Vixie
Current thread:
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news), (continued)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Pekka Savola (Oct 16)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Daniel Roesen (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Valdis . Kletnieks (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Christopher L. Morrow (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) David Conrad (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Christopher L. Morrow (Oct 15)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Crist Clark (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Daniel Roesen (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) David Meyer (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Crist Clark (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Paul Vixie (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) william(at)elan.net (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) David Conrad (Oct 14)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Paul Vixie (Oct 15)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Bill Woodcock (Oct 17)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Tony Li (Oct 17)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Bill Woodcock (Oct 17)
- Re: shim6 (was Re: IPv6 news) Christopher L. Morrow (Oct 14)
- Re: IPv6 news John Payne (Oct 14)
- Re: IPv6 news Christopher L. Morrow (Oct 14)
- Re: IPv6 news Jared Mauch (Oct 14)