nanog mailing list archives

Re: .iq [ was: Re: Paul Vixie serving ORSN ]


From: Bill Woodcock <woody () pch net>
Date: Fri, 30 Sep 2005 14:42:06 -0700 (PDT)


    > Have you got an opinion on .mm? Last December it so happened that 
    > all their servers (in the UK, which isn't part of Burma, or Burma 
    > Shave, or ...) were dark.  If those facts were present today, would 
    > you be ready to delta dot?

My inclination has been to solve problems rather than burn things down...  
Changing the root doesn't solve the problem of all someone's servers being 
down.  Getting a useful (first priority: up, second priority: in and by 
the country of service) set of servers into the root does solve the 
problem.

I think that we (PCH) and ICANN, and RIPE, and Randy Bush, among many 
others, have all put quite a bit of work into trying to see that happen.  
Starting over doesn't build a better system, just a less trusted one.

                                -Bill


Current thread: