nanog mailing list archives
Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc
From: "Patrick W. Gilmore" <patrick () ianai net>
Date: Fri, 7 Apr 2006 07:03:09 -0400
On Apr 7, 2006, at 5:06 AM, Alexander Koch wrote:
I see very often that customers in the US send morespecs all over the place, deaggregate whole /14s or such scary crap, ask us to accept random stuff out of 4/8 and 8/8 (L3 space) by example. I am practically asking what is (if any) the normal way for any of this. I am working by the principle that not everything I could do I should do, especially not right away. Is there any accepted procedure / policy for anyone to a) announce and b) accept (the transit supplier) and have that sanctioned formally? Maybe nobody cares, then tell me. ;-)
There is a lot of "nobody cares", but I'm not sure that accounts for everything you see.
Can you give us some examples so us "dumb Americans" can more precisely explain the problem? :)
Coming from Europe where pretty much everyone is RIPE LIR and has its own /21 at the least I might not see the problem that allegedly some (many) US ISPs do have. Enlighten me. (And, no, I do not fall for the urban legend that RIPE or ARIN are by default evil, clearly not. I do have real- life experience that whenever you can rightfully justify even large IP assignments you do get it.)
What if you try to justify small assignments? -- TTFN, patrick
Current thread:
- IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Alexander Koch (Apr 07)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Patrick W. Gilmore (Apr 07)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Alexander Koch (Apr 07)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Joe Provo (Apr 07)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Stephen Sprunk (Apr 07)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Andy Davidson (Apr 14)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Chris Woodfield (Apr 15)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Owen DeLong (Apr 15)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Charles Gucker (Apr 15)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Alexander Koch (Apr 07)
- Re: IP ranges, re- announcing 'PA space' via BGP, etc Patrick W. Gilmore (Apr 07)