nanog mailing list archives
Re: How to tell if something is anycasted?
From: Martin Hannigan <hannigan () renesys com>
Date: Wed, 17 May 2006 17:21:20 -0400
At 02:11 PM 5/17/2006, Steve Gibbard wrote:
On Wed, 17 May 2006, Martin Hannigan wrote:And there are many, with many TLD's. (rough counts) provider/tld's UDNS 48 ISC 19 PCH 8 PSG 23 ICANN 4 UUNET 61 RIPE 87 DEC 10 NIC.FR 71 Note: There is cross servicing of TLDs counted above. Some numbers may seem low since there seems to be some bit of obfuscation. Or perhaps not and I just haven't confirmed. Some are anycasted, some appear to be physical separations, and some appear to be nested and anycasted i.e. multiple names for the same domain anycasted. I think naming is a bad choice because it's costly to the users and opens the root up to custom configuration by customers which I think is bad. Tagging the route with a community containing the ISO corresponding country could be interesting for location purposes, but of course, that's already been thought of. :)Of Marty's list above, only UltraDNS and PCH are anycast (there are several other anycast networks hosting TLDs that aren't on Marty's list).
Right. They start to get smaller in numbers and less interesting.
The numbers there look odd to me. My data is a six months old (I really need to rerun my script and regenerate it), but my list of /24s and the TLDs they host is at:
http://www.gibbard.org/~scg/infrastructure-distribution/ranked-dns-subnets-051110I assume that in most cases a /24 with multiple DNS server IP addresses being authoritative for TLDs is all run by one entity in a common location or set of locations. UUNet is an exception to the location assumption.
The difference is that you are following the network and I'm following the operator. Thanks for sharing your data. -M< -- Martin Hannigan (c) 617-388-2663 Renesys Corporation (w) 617-395-8574 Member of Technical Staff Network Operationshannigan () renesys com
Current thread:
- How to tell if something is anycasted? David Hubbard (May 16)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Steve Gibbard (May 16)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Edward Lewis (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Edward B. DREGER (May 16)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Peter Boothe (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? bmanning (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Martin Hannigan (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Steve Gibbard (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Joe Abley (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Martin Hannigan (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Gustavo Lozano (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? bmanning (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Joe Abley (May 17)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Peter Boothe (May 18)
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Steve Gibbard (May 16)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: How to tell if something is anycasted? Peter Boothe (May 18)