nanog mailing list archives
Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy...
From: Simon Lyall <simon () darkmere gen nz>
Date: Wed, 15 Aug 2007 21:43:28 +1200 (NZST)
On Tue, 14 Aug 2007, Al Iverson wrote:
On 8/14/07, Douglas Otis <dotis () mail-abuse org> wrote:This comment was added as a follow-on note. Sorry for not being clear. Accepting messages from a domain lacking MX records might be risky due to the high rate of domain turnovers. Within a few weeks, more than the number of existing domains will have been added and deleted by then. Spammers take advantage of this flux. Unfortunately SMTP server discovery via A records is permitted and should be deprecated.Should be (perhaps) but clearly isn't. When you run it through a standards body and/or obtain broad acceptance; great! Until then, it's pipe dreaming.
Okay I wasn't reading this thread but the last few posts have gone a little over the edge. I don't know where this whole "Must have MX record to send email" thing came from but I would have thought domains that don't want to send email can easily mark this fact with a simple SPF record: v=spf1 -all Trying to overload the MX record is pointless when there is a simple method that the domain owners, registrars can choose to use or not. -- Simon Lyall | Very Busy | Web: http://www.darkmere.gen.nz/ "To stay awake all night adds a day to your life" - Stilgar | eMT.
Current thread:
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy..., (continued)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Carl Karsten (Aug 13)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... J Bacher (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Douglas Otis (Aug 13)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Carl Karsten (Aug 13)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Chris L. Morrow (Aug 13)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Tony Finch (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Tim Franklin (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Al Iverson (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Douglas Otis (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Al Iverson (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Simon Lyall (Aug 15)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Mark Andrews (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Douglas Otis (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Chris L. Morrow (Aug 14)
- Re: [policy] When Tech Meets Policy... Mark Andrews (Aug 14)
- Discovering policy Douglas Otis (Aug 15)
- Re: Discovering policy Mark Andrews (Aug 15)
- Re: Discovering policy Douglas Otis (Aug 15)
- Re: Discovering policy Mark Andrews (Aug 15)
- wierd dns thread (Re: Discovering policy) Paul Vixie (Aug 16)
- RE: Discovering policy michael.dillon (Aug 16)