nanog mailing list archives
Re: Network Operations Guide
From: Bill Nash <billn () billn net>
Date: Thu, 23 Aug 2007 08:39:27 -0700 (MST)
On Thu, 23 Aug 2007, Sam Stickland wrote:
Bill Nash wrote:The single most important piece of advice I can offer when building your own tools: Never poll the routing table with SNMP. Ever. Any OTS tool that says it can, as a feature, well, it's a witch, burn it. (You mean like the Cisco Route Manager? *http://www.cisco.com/en/US/products/ps6336/index.html * I not used it myself but the datasheet does say it collects the routing tables via SNMP, with the one cavet: "Prior to a scan, the Cisco Route Manager checks the router's CPU and if the percentage is greater than a configured threshold then it does not scan the route table and moves onto the next router."
That 'feature' right there is a great indicator as to just how unhealthy such an action is. Even if your CPU load is below your threshold, you can't guarantee that the polling action isn't going to put it over that threshold to the point of impacting performance. Break out the Zebra/Quagga install and offload that CPU load. Don't use SNMP to read routing information. Ok, I shouldn't be so declarative about it. You can do whatever you want with your network. I will continue to beat people if/when I catch them doing it. =) - billn
Current thread:
- RE: Network Operations Guide, (continued)
- RE: Network Operations Guide michael.dillon (Aug 22)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Deepak Jain (Aug 22)
- RE: Network Operations Guide michael.dillon (Aug 22)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Scott Francis (Aug 31)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Joel Jaeggli (Aug 22)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Alexander Harrowell (Aug 22)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Bill Nash (Aug 22)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Andrew Sullivan (Aug 22)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Deepak Jain (Aug 23)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Deepak Jain (Aug 22)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Sam Stickland (Aug 23)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Bill Nash (Aug 23)
- Message not available
- Re: Network Operations Guide Bill Nash (Aug 24)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Bill Nash (Aug 24)
- Re: Network Operations Guide Sam Stickland (Aug 31)
- RE: Network Operations Guide michael.dillon (Aug 22)