nanog mailing list archives
Re: Google wants to be your Internet
From: "Brandon Galbraith" <brandon.galbraith () gmail com>
Date: Tue, 23 Jan 2007 11:16:04 -0600
Why is IP required, and even if you used IP for transport why must the meter identification be based on an IP address? If meters only report information, they don't need a unique transport address and could put the meter identifier in the application data. Even if the intent is to include additional controls, e.g. cycle air conditioners during peak periods, you still don't need to use IP or unique IP transport addresses. Just because you have the hammer called IP, doesn't mean you must use it on everything.
Exactly. A meter should be able to connect over an available transport method, and be identifiable via a serial number, not an IP. It may need to grab a DHCP address of some sort (or whatever the moniker is for the transport available), but in the end it's unique serial number should be used to identify itself.
Current thread:
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet, (continued)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Daniel Golding (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Brandon Galbraith (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Alexander Harrowell (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Valdis . Kletnieks (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Donald Stahl (Jan 23)
- RE: Google wants to be your Internet Jamie Bowden (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Saku Ytti (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Bob Martin (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Christian Kuhtz (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Sean Donelan (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Brandon Galbraith (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Andy Davidson (Jan 24)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Marshall Eubanks (Jan 23)
- Fwd: Google wants to be your Internet tvest (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Jeroen Massar (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet J. Oquendo (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Jeroen Massar (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Jeroen Massar (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 23)