nanog mailing list archives
Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions
From: Stephen Sprunk <stephen () sprunk org>
Date: Tue, 26 Aug 2008 09:55:52 -0500
Paul Wall wrote:
On Fri, Aug 22, 2008 at 10:34 AM, Matlock, Kenneth L <MatlockK () exempla org> wrote:Does anyone here have real-world experience with Force 10 gear (Specifically their E-Series and C-Series)? They came and did their whole dog and pony show today, but I wanted to get real-world feedback on their gear. I need to know about their 1) Reliability 2) PerformanceEANTC did a comprehensive study of the E-series: http://www.eantc.de/en/test_reports_presentations/test_reports/force_10_sfm_failover_video_ftos_6211.html http://www.eantc.com/fileadmin/eantc/downloads/test_reports/2006-2008/Cisco-Force10/EANTC_Full_Report.pdf http://www.eantc.com/fileadmin/eantc/downloads/test_reports/2006-2008/Cisco-Force10/Section_8.pdf
Standard benchmarketing. Not that I blame Cisco or EANTC for that, since they were debunking some benchmarketing done by Force10 and Tolly, but consider the source (and follow the money) when reading any "independent" test and what that means for accuracy.
80% of the EANTC report can be summed up as "The default CAM profile didn't do what we wanted, and we didn't bother asking Force10 for the commands to make it work." There are indeed some interesting product weaknesses, like any vendor has, but the fact that Force10's CAM can be partitioned to match the buyer's needs, rather than having a fixed configuration that all customers are forced to use, is an advantage in my book.
S(Disclosure: I am a former employee of both Cisco and Force10, but have no ties to either today.)
Current thread:
- Force10 Gear - Opinions Matlock, Kenneth L (Aug 22)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Jared Mauch (Aug 22)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Paul Wall (Aug 23)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Jo Rhett (Aug 25)
- RE: Force10 Gear - Opinions James Jun (Aug 25)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Paul Wall (Aug 26)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Stephen Sprunk (Aug 26)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Owen DeLong (Aug 26)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Greg VILLAIN (Aug 31)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Jo Rhett (Aug 25)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Jo Rhett (Aug 25)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Rubens Kuhl Jr. (Aug 25)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Paul Wall (Aug 26)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Chris Riling (Aug 26)
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Mikael Abrahamsson (Aug 26)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: Force10 Gear - Opinions Joel Snyder (Aug 24)