nanog mailing list archives
Re: And so it ends...
From: "Patrick W. Gilmore" <patrick () ianai net>
Date: Thu, 3 Feb 2011 11:30:24 -0500
On Feb 3, 2011, at 11:22 AM, Benson Schliesser wrote:
On Feb 3, 2011, at 9:30 AM, Patrick W. Gilmore wrote:On Feb 3, 2011, at 10:11 AM, Jon Lewis wrote:The real fun's going to be over the next several years as the RIR's become irrelevant in the acquisition of scarce IPv4 resources...and things become less stable as lots of orgs rush to implement a strange new IP version.Supposedly[*] transfers between private entities are still supposed to be justified to the local RIRs. (At least that's how it works in ARIN's area.)That's what the RIR might say. But without legal authority (e.g. under contract, as a regulator, or through statutory authority) it is difficult or impossible to enforce.
You missed the [*] where I said "I know, I know...." -- TTFN, patrick
can talk about how people "should" return addresses, or "should" justify transfers, etc, but we would only be begging. Transfers will take place outside the RIR scope, because RIR transfer/market policy doesn't accommodate reality. Or, we can fix policy..? Cheers, -Benson
Current thread:
- And so it ends... Scott Howard (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Wil Schultz (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Jon Lewis (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Patrick W. Gilmore (Feb 03)
- RE: And so it ends (slightly off topic) Ronald Bonica (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends (slightly off topic) Marshall Eubanks (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends (slightly off topic) Alexandre Snarskii (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends (slightly off topic) Leo Bicknell (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends (slightly off topic) Rubens Kuhl (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Jon Lewis (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Benson Schliesser (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Patrick W. Gilmore (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... John Curran (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Benson Schliesser (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... John Curran (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Benson Schliesser (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... John Curran (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Jeffrey Lyon (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Kevin Stange (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Owen DeLong (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Wil Schultz (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... Ernie Rubi (Feb 03)
- Re: And so it ends... John Curran (Feb 03)