nanog mailing list archives

RE: Request Spamhaus contact


From: Nathan Eisenberg <nathan () atlasnetworks us>
Date: Tue, 18 Jan 2011 09:25:42 +0000

It was blocked and I did verify it. A very small amount of our traffic
comes in on PCCW and *they* were not honoring a tag that they've
contractually agreed to honor. I can understand why it may be fun to
make this look like a product of my own incompetence, and perhaps it
is something I would have noticed if I wasn't busy responding to
flames.
 
It may be a good policy going forward to do your own null-routes.  I realize that for a DDOS protection company, the 
ability to tag nullroutes upstream is handy, but you also need to nullroute the traffic on your own gear, or shut down 
the switch port.  Something that is completely independent of another organization, regardless of their contractual 
obligations to you.

If you were my employee, I would find the fact that you fat-fingered a nullroute to be highly concerning.  I would 
recommend that in addition to changing the way you do nullroutes, you also implement a change control policy which 
screens commands for approval before making configuration changes upon which your public declarations, and your 
reputation as a decent operator, rely.

Nathan Eisenberg



Current thread: