nanog mailing list archives
Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers?
From: Jay Ashworth <jra () baylink com>
Date: Sat, 3 Sep 2011 10:17:40 -0400 (EDT)
----- Original Message -----
From: "Skeeve Stevens" <Skeeve () eintellego net>
I've been thinking about the impact that iCloud (by Apple) will have on the Internet.
Aw, c'mon; what a boring Whacky Weekend thread... :-)
So basically the potential issue is that a large residential provider could have thousands of users connect to iCloud, their connections slowed because of uploading data, burning their included bandwidth caps, slowing down the backhaul segment of the network, and as residential providers are mostly download, some purchase transit from their upstreams in an symmetric fashion.
IOW: The Tragedy Of The Commons. Yup; this is definitely going to be fun. This is, I think, slightly different from the Netflix Instant arguments we always have: the ones wherein it's pointed out that carriers aren't really entitled to charge Netflix because they've made improper bets on their capacity engineering for What Might Come Next: Apple really had better have already *known* what the engineering of consumer grade Internet looked like (or several high level product and engineering people are dangerously underqualified for their jobs), so as this problem gets worse, and I concur that it will, the result will be that they bet wrong. Gambling means that sometimes you lose. Alas, the costs won't be on Apple. This seems to be an ongoing situation: carriers discovering that they also bet wrong on how to engineer the network: they've been making the beams thinner and thinner, and then along came something reasonably rational... that was heavy enough to break them. Anyone betting carriers will stop gambling quite so hard, and build networks the way John Roebling built bridges? Cheers, -- jr 'first woodpecker that came along...' a -- Jay R. Ashworth Baylink jra () baylink com Designer The Things I Think RFC 2100 Ashworth & Associates http://baylink.pitas.com 2000 Land Rover DII St Petersburg FL USA http://photo.imageinc.us +1 727 647 1274
Current thread:
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers?, (continued)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Jay Ashworth (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Seth Mattinen (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Jay Ashworth (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Valdis . Kletnieks (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Jared Mauch (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Phil Pierotti (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Seth Mos (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Måns Nilsson (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Skeeve Stevens (Sep 05)
- Re: iCloud - Is it going to hurt access providers? Vincent C Jones (Sep 06)