nanog mailing list archives
Re: Filter on IXP
From: Jay Ashworth <jra () baylink com>
Date: Fri, 28 Feb 2014 11:00:51 -0500 (EST)
----- Original Message -----
From: "Jérôme Nicolle" <jerome () ceriz fr>
Le 23/02/2014 01:43, Chris Laffin a écrit :It would be really cool if peering exchanges could police ntp on their connected members.Well, THIS looks like the worst idea ever. Wasting ASIC ressources on IXP's dataplanes is a wet-dream for anyone willing to kill the network. IXP's neutrality is a key factor to maintain reasonable interconnexion density. Instead, IXPs _could_ enforce BCP38 too. Mapping the route-server's received routes to ingress _and_ egress ACLs on IXP ports would mitigate the role of BCP38 offenders within member ports. It's almost like uRPF in an intelligent and useable form.
Interesting. Are you doing this? Planning it? Or at least researching how well it would work?
A noticeable side-effect is that members would be encouraged to announce their entire customer-cones to ensure egress trafic from a non-exchanged prefix would not be dropped on the IX's port.
Don't they do this already? If you get something practical implemented on this topic, we'd be more than pleased to see it show up on bcp38.info; exchange points are the one major construct I hadn't included there, cause I didn't think it was actually practical to do it there. But then, I don't run one. Cheers, -- jra -- Jay R. Ashworth Baylink jra () baylink com Designer The Things I Think RFC 2100 Ashworth & Associates http://www.bcp38.info 2000 Land Rover DII St Petersburg FL USA BCP38: Ask For It By Name! +1 727 647 1274
Current thread:
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size?, (continued)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Jimmy Hess (Feb 26)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Niels Bakker (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Randy Bush (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Niels Bakker (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Robert Drake (Feb 26)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Keegan Holley (Feb 27)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Jimmy Hess (Feb 26)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Robert Drake (Feb 26)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Cb B (Feb 25)
- Re: Filter on IXP Jérôme Nicolle (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter on IXP Jay Ashworth (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter on IXP Jérôme Nicolle (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter on IXP Randy Bush (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter on IXP Jérôme Nicolle (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter on IXP Nick Hilliard (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter on IXP Patrick W. Gilmore (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter on IXP Jérôme Nicolle (Feb 28)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? Saku Ytti (Feb 22)
- Re: Filter NTP traffic by packet size? James R Cutler (Feb 20)