nanog mailing list archives
Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation
From: William Herrin <bill () herrin us>
Date: Thu, 24 Jul 2014 18:28:02 -0400
On Thu, Jul 24, 2014 at 6:10 PM, Jay Ashworth <jra () baylink com> wrote:
For the record, Eric, I'm certain that states can preempt municipalities.
Howdy, Actually, it usually stands on its head: states determine the scope of what local governments are -permitted- and required to do rather than what they're forbidden. Traditionally, sanctioning the local cable TV company has been one of the activities the states assign to individual localities while sanctioning the local telephone company has been kept up at the state corporation commission or public utilities commission. With the convergence of cable TV and telephone into Internet, it's anybody's guess which regulation goes where. Everybody wants the power. Nobody wants the responsibility.
The question is can FCC preempt States?
Generally yes, as long as there is some aspect of the activity that moves it into the realm of interstate commerce. The FCC would have trouble preempting the states on a pure layer-1 fiber build but it is within the federal government's authority to preempt state regulation on general Internet access and any infrastructure not meticulously separated from the same. For example, the FCC preempts all state and local regulation of sub-meter satellite dishes on the grounds that satellite communications is fundamentally interstate in nature. They even preempt homeowners' association rules. There's also the question of whether the FCC already has the authority or if they'd need an act of congress to get it. On that question, I have no idea. Regards, Bill Herrin -- William Herrin ................ herrin () dirtside com bill () herrin us Owner, Dirtside Systems ......... Web: <http://www.dirtside.com/> Can I solve your unusual networking challenges?
Current thread:
- Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation Eric Brunner-Williams (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation Jay Ashworth (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation William Herrin (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation Roy (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation William Herrin (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation Roy (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation William Herrin (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation Jay Ashworth (Jul 24)
- Re: Correspondence to the FCC re: preemption of local government as a source of regulation Miles Fidelman (Jul 24)