nanog mailing list archives
Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX
From: Nick Hilliard <nick () foobar org>
Date: Mon, 29 Feb 2016 13:19:58 +0000
Pavel Odintsov wrote:
From hardware point of view almost all brand new switches support sflow free of charge (no additional licenses or modules). But be aware, Cisco do not support this protocol at all (that's pretty weird, really).
sflow is supported on the Nexus 3k range, but it's available as ingress + egress only, non-configurable (despite the fact that the option to configure is available at the chipset level). This means that you can't define an account perimeter on the switch, which makes it mostly useless from a production point of view. Pretty much every other switch on the market will allow you to specify either ingress or egress. The only consistent explanation I can suggest for Cisco's vehement antipathy towards sflow is "not invented here". It's supported in hardware by several of the other chipsets that Cisco uses, but left non-enabled in software. TBH it's a short sighted and disappointing approach to telemetry. Nick
Current thread:
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX, (continued)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Roland Dobbins (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Pavel Odintsov (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Roland Dobbins (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Pavel Odintsov (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Roland Dobbins (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Edward Dore (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Pavel Odintsov (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Edward Dore (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Pavel Odintsov (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Nick Hilliard (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Nick Hilliard (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Nikolay Shopik (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Pavel Odintsov (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Saku Ytti (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX sthaug (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Saku Ytti (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Nick Hilliard (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Saku Ytti (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Phil Bedard (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Saku Ytti (Feb 29)
- Re: sFlow vs netFlow/IPFIX Avi Freedman (Feb 28)