nanog mailing list archives
Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames?
From: Saku Ytti <saku () ytti fi>
Date: Wed, 9 Mar 2016 18:20:05 +0200
On 9 March 2016 at 16:34, Job Snijders <job () instituut net> wrote:
https://www.nanog.org/sites/default/files/wednesday.general.steenbergen.antijumbo.pdf
IXP can verify if MTU is too large or too small with active poller. Poller in the IXP has too large MTU, it tries to send ping packets with max_size+1, if they work, customer has too large MTU. Also it tries to send max_size, if it does not work, customer has too small MTU. As icing on top, it tries to send max_size+1 but fragments it to max_size and 1, and sees what comes back. IXP is only interface in whole of Internet which collapses MTU to 1500B, private peers regularly have higher MTU, ~everyone runs core at higher MTU. I think it's crucial that we stop thinking MTU as single thing, we should separate edge MTU and core MTU, that is how we already think and provision when we think about our own network. Then question becomes, is IXP edge or core? I would say run core MTU in IXP, so edge MTU can be tunneled without fragmentation over it. IXP can offer edgeMTU and coreMTU VLANs, so that people who are religiously against it, can only peer in edgeMTU VLAN. -- ++ytti
Current thread:
- Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Kurt Kraut via NANOG (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Grzegorz Janoszka (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Hugo Slabbert (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Job Snijders (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Saku Ytti (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nick Hilliard (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Saku Ytti (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nick Hilliard (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Saku Ytti (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nick Hilliard (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Saku Ytti (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Aris Lambrianidis (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nick Hilliard (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Saku Ytti (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nick Hilliard (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Saku Ytti (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Grzegorz Janoszka (Mar 09)