nanog mailing list archives
Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet
From: Eric Dugas <edugas () unknowndevice ca>
Date: Thu, 28 Mar 2019 09:08:26 -0400
I have a policy applied to my upstreams and peers to deny the IXP's LANs were connected to. I don't think of any reason to learn these routes from someone else's network. On Wed, Mar 27, 2019 at 7:44 PM Cummings, Chris <ccummings () coeur com> wrote:
Not too sure about your topology, but I’ve had something similar bite me, so we typically put a prefix list inbound to deny receiving our internal prefixes from our peers. This probably doesn’t work as well if your network is less “eyeballish” than ours, however. /chris On Wed, Mar 27, 2019 at 4:37 PM -0500, "Graham Johnston" < johnstong () westmancom com> wrote: This afternoon at around 12:17 central time today we began learning thesubnet for the Equinix IX in Chicago via a transit provider; we are on the IX as well. The subnet in question is 208.115.136.0/23. Using stat.ripe.net <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net&c=E,1,HdSVqYeR7jgCV-Dur66y05aHEW-BSduVIIHYHrXZ1P6qOt3fa684wgoFR9CoVMgOpEaWMO0lwDjZkSR-n80nd7Rvcqp4MKodaGyrIDIjEhtPXiDie1SaYsyZJ9ed&typo=1> I can see that this subnet is also being learned by others, see the snip below. On our network this caused a nasty routing loop until we figured out what was wrong. My current best understanding is that because the route was learned via eBGP it trumped the OSPF learned route. As soon as I filtered the advertisement from my transit provider everything returned to normal. What am I doing that isn’t best practices that would have prevented this? Thanks, graham RIPE Info *1* RRCs see *1* peers announcing *208.115.136.0/23 <http://208.115.136.0/23>* originated by *AS32703* <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2fAS32703&c=E,1,TOo4BxuZBilA6dEeEsyArFdQvYciFoXF4XjZNU4NqyzUFPawLd-3hzV5XwlwfBLIcVRBns_GfdJCxNBaU2dYqDWisxgCxwxRPMoTfXq-TRSDQa_BgAvqRg,,&typo=1> · ▼RRC00 in *Amsterdam, Netherlands* sees *1* ASN orginating *208.115.136.0/23 <http://208.115.136.0/23>*.AS32703 o ▼*AS32703 <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2fAS32703&c=E,1,LPjxozPn3-dGOA9bDJB081OscbzusnfrxssBxyMbOyunZUcNyeibk_RHV8UYO3Fw77TpLU9yRsywr6KjrmyXWgKk4DQ7XRSgr1_W1SNgkfA,&typo=1>* is seen as the origin by *1* peer.192.102.254.1 § ▼*192.102.254.1 <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2f192.102.254.1&c=E,1,fW5rffxlYLANo-g3GopSdMyHH2oIqoulMERJOjPrrdRL4Z8602v0WhaVuS6ignBPzPDgh4S05V55mLAGu_OFn1TzFyYcCpMMzTgH1ejtJmILMrcaDQDn&typo=1>* is announcing route *AS395152* <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2fAS395152&c=E,1,I_iMCTImXK-T7Vj5VALSLMN6lo0N3-N2qYG7QlBHNK8oXNmPQnsp4zJy424NN2Y8z2WxSBIfaPSkLoibtnClWliVcGMhdMDsIewEnAgiZaRITyPjKA,,&typo=1> *AS63297* <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2fAS63297&c=E,1,V7oySywzIc8rSc64KXotimJVgetH1G5VqJoedNuNjm9JbOYDh8qrdMlVKD12tKJtJ4STBfu9kLFuBXInbfko44ryiCz5Gy2CztDGyYXF4HJW6Jm3uPvJgOUAfTc,&typo=1> *AS6327* <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2fAS6327&c=E,1,4wIITl8037dr3SSHzQmbAIwgiFe3X75-DkFAlERAGWEFjFROhFPMC2c3IGy_vChkNN-YI2OoobMvhOUKjiV9mt69N8kXl_RTvv22nZHKLJkYc59V&typo=1> *AS36280* <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2fAS36280&c=E,1,_jAHKYzgyGwMDV4H1HRk1FK3bV5j_t6dSn2YfYhnhLBYub5v33-ryduZ34KVZYUy19lhSRThf8TUnUT_6V35nTMLw6SCXqY0S8bggDBKvYUg&typo=1> *AS32703* <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2fstat.ripe.net%2fAS32703&c=E,1,RAfxFbCQUejEFosUxg2dek9Ke5qatnE5GGjP6p2ovv1XL6hN77GlayI0Nm5jA_jRLCxzzaZQUdABGyy7HlA7bi93SIbytUbKx_49kJPC168,&typo=1> . § Origin: IGP § Next Hop: 192.102.254.1 § Peer: 192.102.254.1 § Community: 63297:1000 § AS Path: 395152 63297 6327 36280 32703 § Last Updated: 2019-03-27T17:17:19 Route-views route-views.chicago.routeviews.org <https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=https%3a%2f%2froute-views.chicago.routeviews.org&c=E,1,E0igNv77g9AAa2d6Uaxl8p-e1C0XIX7IzMRDUURg85DkFqIFTzckgumVyHoZqhybvGEz7rGGqi_cSc8KzJW5xx3nxdSBkfe6z_hdXiip8re7qfTpyjS1o2wzcvLw&typo=1>> show ip bgp 208.115.136.0 BGP routing table entry for 208.115.136.0/23 Paths: (1 available, best #1, table Default-IP-Routing-Table) Not advertised to any peer 32709 32703 208.115.136.134 from 208.115.136.134 (63.134.128.248) Origin IGP, localpref 100, valid, external, best AddPath ID: RX 0, TX 64414249 Last update: Wed Mar 27 17:16:09 2019
Current thread:
- Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Graham Johnston (Mar 27)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Nick Hilliard (Mar 27)
- RE: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Graham Johnston (Mar 27)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Cummings, Chris (Mar 27)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Eric Dugas (Mar 28)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Christopher Morrell (Mar 28)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Niels Bakker (Mar 28)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Job Snijders (Mar 28)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Eric Dugas (Mar 28)
- Re: Advertisement of Equinix Chicago IX Subnet Nick Hilliard (Mar 27)