nanog mailing list archives
Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network
From: Matt Corallo <nanog () as397444 net>
Date: Tue, 3 Mar 2020 15:20:01 -0500
Note, of course, further, that "the GFW" is not a single appliance, nor even a standard, common appliance. There are very different "GFWs" based on which link you're looking at, which telco it is, etc. Indeed, usually traffic to Hong Kong is effected much less by the GFW than other links (though still passes through *a* GFW). I've also found traffic destined to Khabarovsk (depending on the routing) to pass through GFWs which rarely cause issue. Matt On 3/3/20 1:28 PM, Rubens Kuhl wrote:
On Tue, Mar 3, 2020 at 3:23 PM Jakob Heitz (jheitz) via NANOG <nanog () nanog org <mailto:nanog () nanog org>> wrote: I can corroborate that. I visited China in August 2019 and had terrible internet performance to sites outside of China. This was both with mobile and wifi at the homes of two friends, one in Heilongjiang and the other in Beijing. When I visited in February 2015, it was much better. Both times, I was using VNC on the company VPN. This does not use much bandwidth, but is quite latency sensitive. GFW has some different settings that they use, similar to "ThreatCon"... if civil unrest is happening, its working is changed. During party conventions, they change it too. So when a foreign visits China, that experience might be different from one visiting during a different time period. Also, some hotels that only accept international guests backhaul traffic thru Hong Kong, providing an experience that looks much closer to US/Europe broadband. Rubens
Current thread:
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network, (continued)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Pengxiong Zhu (Mar 21)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Valdis Klētnieks (Mar 02)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Pengxiong Zhu (Mar 02)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network David Burns (Mar 02)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Pengxiong Zhu (Mar 02)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Ben Cannon (Mar 15)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Mark Tinka (Mar 03)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Scott Weeks (Mar 02)
- RE: China’s Slow Transnational Network Jakob Heitz (jheitz) via NANOG (Mar 03)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Rubens Kuhl (Mar 03)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Matt Corallo (Mar 03)
- Re: China’s Slow Transnational Network Rubens Kuhl (Mar 03)