Re: Changes to the filesystem while find is running - comments?

[psz () maths usyd edu au (Paul Szabo)]

James,

You asked on bugtraq:

> GNU find does a sanity check before and after calling chdir().  It
> stats the directory it's about to move into, and stats "." after
> chdir() succeeds.  It then compares the device numbers and inode
> numbers returned by he two stat() calls.  This is done in a function
> called wd_sanity_check().  If these are different, find prints an
> error and exits fatally (in versions up to and including GNU findutils
> 4.2.5.
> ...
> [ Shenanigans with automounter upset wd_sanity_check() ]
> As of findutils 4.2.6/4.2.7, find will read /etc/mtab ...
> [ Shenanigans in Solaris automounter upset mtab check ]
> ... Hence my question is :-
>     Is it worthwhile at all to perform this "sanity check" or is it of 
>     insufficient benefit?
> I'd be grateful for your thoughts.

What I would like to see implemented (in some messy pseudo-code, starting
in parent directory):

  PARENT=stat(".");
  SUBDIR=stat("subdir");
  chdir("subdir");
  DOT=stat(".");
  if (SUBDIR != DOT) {
    Print warning message
  }
  else {
    Go on with find (recurse)
  }
  chdir("..");
  DOT=stat(".");
  if (PARENT != DOT) {
    Print message
    Exit with fatal error
  }

Do not descend into "dodgy" directories, but back out of them; exit fatally
if you cannot get back to solid ground.

Is this doable?

Cheers,

Paul Szabo - psz () maths usyd edu au  http://www.maths.usyd.edu.au:8000/u/psz/
School of Mathematics and Statistics  University of Sydney   2006  Australia