Full Disclosure mailing list archives
it's all about timing
From: full-disclosure () lists netsys com (Eric N. Valor)
Date: Wed, 31 Jul 2002 20:06:36 -0700
I believe, depending on severity of the vulnerability, that one week should be sufficient for at least vendor response prior to publically leaking information about said vulnerability. This does not mean releasing exploit code, only general information about the vuln so that educated readers can understand what's going on. If no vendor responses occur, then release of information should occur. If there is vendor response indicating an attempt to work the issue, then more time should of course be given (again, depending on severity of the issue). Holes in this would include exactly *how* the vendor was contacted (midnight messages left in the general company voicemail don't count, etc.) and whether any follow-up attempts were made. Also, a vanilla vendor response to the effect of "Thank you for the information. We'll look into it. Don't call us, we'll call you" is an effective NOOP. Are we enough of an ad-hoc "authority" to attempt to determine a proper course of action for these instances? Codifying this (even if it's just a "gentlemen's agreement") would most definitely be A Good Thing. -- Eric N. Valor ericv () cruzio com PGP Key 2048/1024 227B04CB Key Fingerprint = 766C CA15 0FFF E54B 2FEE C7D7 0F87 3AFB 227B 04CB : This Space Intentionally Left Blank :
Current thread:
- it's all about timing Tom Perrine (Jul 31)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- it's all about timing Snow, Corey (Jul 31)
- it's all about timing James Martin (Jul 31)
- it's all about timing Eric N. Valor (Jul 31)
- it's all about timing Jonathan Rickman (Jul 31)
- it's all about timing Joey Kelly (Aug 01)
- it's all about timing Ron DuFresne (Aug 01)
- it's all about timing Jonathan Rickman (Jul 31)
- it's all about timing full-disclosure () lists netsys com (Jul 31)
- Re: it's all about timing Steven M. Christey (Jul 31)
- Re: it's all about timing Georgi Guninski (Aug 01)
- Re: it's all about timing Tom Perrine (Aug 01)
- Re: it's all about timing Georgi Guninski (Aug 01)
- Re: it's all about timing Adam Megacz (Jul 31)
- RE: it's all about timing Scott, Richard (Aug 01)
- Re: it's all about timing Sunil James (Aug 01)