nanog mailing list archives
Re: The questions stand
From: Jim Browne <nanog () pup com>
Date: Wed, 20 May 1998 14:35:43 -0700
At 17:17 -0400 5/20/98, Jay R. Ashworth wrote:
If I start the Tampa Bay Internet Exchange, let's say, and I haul in OC-3 links from the 5 top backbones, and DS-3's to the 4 NAP's, I can then (very likely) a) resell bandwidth to local ISP's for quite a bit less than the backbones could sell them a local drop, which would b) be quintuply redundant in cast of feed failure, and c) unload all the cross provider traffic from the NAP's, and indeed, the backbone itself.
No one is stopping you. No one is stopping SAVVIS, either which is doing similar work in the major metro areas. Differences do exist of course. Primarily the fact that you wouldn't be interconnecting such arrangements located in different areas.
In fact, I could operate the exchange as a co-op, _owned_ by all the local providers.
That has already happened in a number of rural areas and some metro areas (Colorado Co-op?). The problem traditionally has been getting small competing providers to cooperate.
Except for the back bone operators, who's best interests is such a scheme _not_ it?
If you are telling me that MCI, et. al. won't sell you DS3 connections you might have a point. I doubt that is the case. As for redundancy, five connections through a single physical location does not constitute a redundant network. Jim Browne jbrowne () jbrowne com "Lesson: PC's have a `keyboard lock' switch, and it works." - Kevin Brick, after RMA'ing a motherboard with a "bad keyboard connector"
Current thread:
- The questions stand Pickett, David (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Karl Denninger (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Richard Irving (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Karl Denninger (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Michael Dillon (May 20)
- Message not available
- Re: The questions stand Jay R. Ashworth (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Brian Horvitz (May 20)
- Message not available
- Re: The questions stand Jay R. Ashworth (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Jim Browne (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Jim Dixon (May 25)
- Re: The questions stand Brian Horvitz (May 21)
- Re: The questions stand Richard Irving (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand Karl Denninger (May 20)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: The questions stand Rob Wilson (May 20)
- Re: The questions stand John Fraizer - Administrator (May 21)
- Message not available
- Re: The questions stand Jay R. Ashworth (May 21)
- Message not available
- Re: The questions stand Karl Denninger (May 21)
- Re: The questions stand Scott Gardner Anderson (May 26)