nanog mailing list archives
Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?)
From: William Allen Simpson <wsimpson () greendragon com>
Date: Tue, 22 Feb 2000 06:11:54 -0500
bmanning () vacation karoshi com wrote:
actually, I think both efforts have about the same level of effort. In one case, its concentrated in a single place, in the other, its all over the place.
I disagree. The point of my proposal was that the collection was automated using current tools, just collecting our query results into our own database. The database would require some effort, but only by the few (2**4) folks coordinating the databases. The other nice thing about my proposal is that we could clean up the data in its central location. Enforcement would be the users (us) adding notations that the data is bad, or entries to fix the data, after beating our heads against the wall trying to find the parties. Your proposal requires every domain/address to add data to their servers. That's millions of locations. There's no enforcement, and therefore, it won't happen anytime soon. As an example of how fast that might be, look at how well in-addr is currently maintained. WSimpson () UMich edu Key fingerprint = 17 40 5E 67 15 6F 31 26 DD 0D B9 9B 6A 15 2C 32
Current thread:
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?), (continued)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Jeff Mcadams (Feb 21)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Roeland M.J. Meyer (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) William Allen Simpson (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Bill Woodcock (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) bmanning (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) J.D. Falk (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) bmanning (Feb 21)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Roeland M.J. Meyer (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) bmanning (Feb 22)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Roeland M.J. Meyer (Feb 22)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) William Allen Simpson (Feb 22)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Rodney Joffe (Feb 21)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Rachel Luxemburg (Feb 21)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Randy Bush (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) John R. Levine (Feb 21)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Tim Salo (Feb 21)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Patrick Greenwell (Feb 22)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Alex Bligh (Feb 22)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Randy Bush (Feb 22)
- RE: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Roeland M.J. Meyer (Feb 21)
- Re: Alternatives (was Re: whois broke again?) Dana Hudes (Feb 21)