nanog mailing list archives
RE: RFC 1918
From: John Fraizer <nanog () EnterZone Net>
Date: Fri, 14 Jul 2000 19:05:21 -0400 (EDT)
OARnet is doing it for "security" last I talked to them (which was several years ago), they've been using RFC1918 on transit links for a while now, CIP ohio-dmz.net. -jamie
Security? I have not, nor do I plan to, but I can think of tons of different points on OARnet directly and two places offnet that one could inject packets into their network and get to those routers, 1918 addressed or not. What ever happened to using good old access-lists on the router for security and blocking traffic destined for the router itself at the borders? It seems to be a much better security model than using 1918 space on the routers. Beyond that, it lets you actually have REAL in-addr.arpa replies for the WAN interfaces in a traceroute. Then again, being an OS-hUge activity, it is very much in character for them to do things their own way and damn the world if they don't like it. I'm convinced that the only thing OS-hUge breeds is primadonnas with a worthless piece of paper that proves they wasted their money and several years of their life. --- John Fraizer EnterZone, Inc
Current thread:
- Re: RFC 1918, (continued)
- Re: RFC 1918 Steven M. Bellovin (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Greg A. Woods (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Shawn McMahon (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Bennett Todd (Jul 16)
- Re: RFC 1918 John Fraizer (Jul 16)
- Re: Path-MTU-discovery Greg A. Woods (Jul 16)
- Re: Path-MTU-discovery Mikael Abrahamsson (Jul 16)
- Message not available
- Re: Path-MTU-discovery Patrick W. Gilmore (Jul 16)
- Re: Path-MTU-discovery Mikael Abrahamsson (Jul 17)
- Re: RFC 1918 Greg A. Woods (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Steven M. Bellovin (Jul 14)
- RE: RFC 1918 John Fraizer (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Todd R. Stroup (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 John Fraizer (Jul 15)
- Re: RFC 1918 Bill Fumerola (Jul 15)
- Re: RFC 1918 Eric A. Hall (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Rick (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Richard A. Steenbergen (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Dan Hollis (Jul 14)
- Re: RFC 1918 Greg A. Woods (Jul 16)