nanog mailing list archives
RE: Definition of a burstable circuit
From: "Youse, Chuck" <Chuck.Youse () ebone com>
Date: Wed, 22 Aug 2001 21:39:15 +0200
Jon Stanley said:
Without getting into a religious debate, I need some consensus for a
problem
that I am having regarding the definition of a burstable circuit.
In my view of the world, a burstable circuit is defined as one where the
customer
can send us as much data as they would like (for example, an entire DS3's
worth
on a consistent basis), and we would bill them for usage above the
contracted amount
via some method (we use 90th percentile reporting)
In someone else's view inside the company, the customer should be
prohibited
from sending above the contracted rate for any extended period of time by
policing
at the ATM layer. Both views are viable, but I believe (nearly
religously)
that the former view is correct.
At Ebone, 'burstable' is equivalent to your first definition. The assumption is that more bandwidth is available, and can be used by the customer, but at a premium rate. Of course, the premium rate is charged to discourage customers from continuously overstepping their committed bandwidth numbers. It effects a similar control over network utilisation as your colleague's definition, but it also affords the customer more flexibility and generates additional revenues. The latter definition would be something that I would more closely associate with frame relay services. I.e., rates above the CIR are available but not guaranteed. To artificially rate-limit a customer's bandwidth is a disservice to them, even if it does make provisioning slightly more deterministic. - C
Current thread:
- Definition of a burstable circuit Stanley, Jon (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Andy Dills (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Jim Mercer (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Patrick Greenwell (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Alex Bligh (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Alex Bligh (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Alex Bligh (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Kevin Gannon (Aug 22)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: Definition of a burstable circuit Youse, Chuck (Aug 22)
- Re: Definition of a burstable circuit Andy Dills (Aug 22)