nanog mailing list archives
RE: Kremen's Buddy?
From: Michael.Dillon () btradianz com
Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2006 10:44:21 +0100
"From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs"
could
be replaced with "From each according to the ARIN fee schedule, to each according to our impossible to decipher allocation templates". Marx
would be
proud! Centrally managed economic systems seem so wonderful on paper - that's why so many otherwise very smart people have championed the idea. Real world experience, on the other hand, has shown that capitalism is
the
worst possible method for distributing resources - except for all the
other
methods, which are even worse.
Your tirade is a typical example of Marxist rhetoric. It may sound good on paper but it does not work in the real world. For an authentic example of such intellectual argument, read this http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1875/gotha/ch01.htm by a famous German intellectual whose tomb is in London's Highgate cemetery. It's only the 1st of 4 chapters, but if you stick to it, not only will you begin to understand why theoretical arguments can be pointless, you will also discover the origin of one of the most well known quotes in the sphere of economics.
And, if people have noticed, the Internet is what we use to make money, these days - at least, the folks on this list.
The fact that the Internet is what we use to make money is the main reason why most of us do not want to make any major changes to the infrastructure that enables the Internet such as ARIN itself. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
My opinion is that ARIN should use some of its not inconsiderable
warchest
and hire some economists to do some real work on modalities for address distribution (i.e. give some grants). Aside from the practical utility,
some
real science around this topic would be of great intellectual benefit.
As I said, a meaningless intellectual exercise... --Michael Dillon
Current thread:
- Re: Kremen's Buddy?, (continued)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Joe Abley (Sep 12)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Tom Vest (Sep 12)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Stephane Bortzmeyer (Sep 13)
- friends? you got friends? bmanning (Sep 12)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Michael . Dillon (Sep 13)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Jack Bates (Sep 13)
- ARIN sucks? was Re: Kremen's Buddy? Albert Meyer (Sep 13)
- Re: ARIN sucks? was Re: Kremen's Buddy? Hank Nussbacher (Sep 13)
- Re: ARIN sucks? was Re: Kremen's Buddy? Alain Hebert (Sep 14)
- Re: ARIN sucks? was Re: Kremen's Buddy? virendra rode // (Sep 14)
- RE: Kremen's Buddy? Michael . Dillon (Sep 13)
- RE: Kremen's Buddy? Justin M. Streiner (Sep 12)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Stephen Sprunk (Sep 12)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Joe Abley (Sep 12)
- Re: Kremen's Buddy? Michael . Dillon (Sep 13)