nanog mailing list archives
Re: Questions about populating RIR with customer information.
From: Leigh Porter <leigh.porter () ukbroadband com>
Date: Wed, 01 Aug 2007 15:23:05 +0100
We always used to put full customer details in RIPE for AS6765 and AS5378. I never had any issues or queries from anybody, they were just told that this is how it is done. -- Leigh Porter Steven Champeon wrote:
on Wed, Aug 01, 2007 at 09:47:45AM -0400, Drew Weaver wrote:Up until recently, we were only providing the RIR database with information about our larger allocations /24 or larger. We have noticed however that many anti-spam organizations such as Spamhaus, and Fiveten will use the lack of information regarding an IP allocation as a blank check to blacklist entire /24s when they are really targeting a single /30 or a /29.It's not just Spamhaus. How do you expect *anyone* to know whether an abusive customer of yours has a /29 or a /18 unless you *tell us* in rwhois? We happily block large swaths of the network due to failure on the providers' parts to adequately describe the allocation. rDNS scans and guesswork are fine, but it's much better if we can count on the providers' actual assignments as published in rwhois and block the smaller allocations instead.Is there some way that we can 'proxy' the information so that it simply states that the /29 has been allocated to a customer but it doesn't provide their contact information?Why on earth would you want to do that? In a world where 90%+ of our inbound mail traffic is abuse, I think accountability trumps privacy. Anyone using those stupid cloaked whois listings is automatic fodder for the filters here. Your right to access my resources ends when you deny me the ability to identify you if I so choose, on evidence of ill intent.
Current thread:
- Questions about populating RIR with customer information. Drew Weaver (Aug 01)
- RE: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. michael.dillon (Aug 01)
- Re: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. Douglas Otis (Aug 02)
- Re: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. Steven Champeon (Aug 01)
- Re: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. Leigh Porter (Aug 01)
- Re: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. Steve Atkins (Aug 01)
- Re: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. Florian Weimer (Aug 01)
- Re: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. James Hess (Aug 02)
- RE: Questions about populating RIR with customer information. michael.dillon (Aug 01)