nanog mailing list archives
RE: Google wants to be your Internet
From: <michael.dillon () bt com>
Date: Wed, 24 Jan 2007 08:33:53 -0000
We also see this with extranet/supply-chain-type connectivity between large companies who have overlapping address space, and I'm afraid it's only going to become more common as more of these types of relationships are established.
Fortunately, IP addresses are not intended for use on the Internet. Rather, they are intended for use with Internet Protocol (IP) implementations. That's why the RIRs, in alignment with RFC 2050, section 3(a), do give out IP address allocations to organizations who are connected to extranet-type networks. If you read RFC 1918, section 2, category 3, you will see that this is consistent. So if the power companies want to assign a unique network address to all power meters then there is no good reason to stop them. After all, it is consistent with the goals of the original IP designers to address every light switch and toaster. Just remember, IP addresses are *NOT* Internet addresses. They are Internet Protocol addresses. Connection to the Internet and public announcement of prefixes are totally irrelevant. --Michael Dillon
Current thread:
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet, (continued)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Jeroen Massar (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Nicholas Suan (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Jim Shankland (Jan 22)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Chris L. Morrow (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Sean Donelan (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Adrian Chadd (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 23)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 20)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 24)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Mark Smith (Jan 24)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 24)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Jason LeBlanc (Jan 24)
- RE: Google wants to be your Internet Jamie Bowden (Jan 24)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Joe Abley (Jan 24)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Roland Dobbins (Jan 24)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Joseph S D Yao (Jan 29)
- Re: Google wants to be your Internet Henning Brauer (Jan 29)