nanog mailing list archives
Re: ISP CALEA compliance
From: Sean Donelan <sean () donelan com>
Date: Fri, 11 May 2007 00:32:23 -0400 (EDT)
On Thu, 10 May 2007, Joe Provo wrote:
Highly likely for most old requests. Your voice folks can tell you the #1 CALEA request is neither kiddie pron nor terrrists, but rather DEA.
Remember, CALEA compliance is separate from any intercept orders youreceive. If you ask your voice folks, you'll also find out very few current voice intercepts actually use CALEA compliant equipment or capabilities.
CALEA is primarily concerned with the interception of real-time communications, and doesn't included access to stored records.
http://www.access.gpo.gov/uscode/title47/chapter9_subchapteri_.html Also if you talk to your voice guys who have been doing this for many years, you'll discover everytime an telephone engineer opened his mouth and said "what about this," the response from the government was "yes, we want that too, even though we don't understand what it is."
Anyone concerned with broadband CALEA should check with their legal team and officers to see who if anyone signed off on the securities manual form 445 and form 105 SSI. Dealines were in February and March, so if your legal believes you are needing to comply, they should have already handled the matter.
Yep, that's why you have lawyers and legal departments. CALEA is notan engineering problem, its a legal/budget problem. Whose legal and budget is going to pay for it, and who doesn't.
Current thread:
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance, (continued)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Steven M. Bellovin (May 11)
- RE: ISP CALEA compliance Stasiniewicz, Adam (May 10)
- RE: ISP CALEA compliance Sean Donelan (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Jeff Shultz (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Jack Bates (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Donald Stahl (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Stephen Sprunk (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Jack Bates (May 11)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Donald Stahl (May 11)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Joe Provo (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Sean Donelan (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance David Lesher (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Stephen Satchell (May 10)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance William Allen Simpson (May 11)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Steven M. Bellovin (May 11)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Sean Donelan (May 11)
- Re: ISP CALEA compliance Joe Provo (May 12)