nanog mailing list archives
Re: Upstream BGP community support
From: Joel Jaeggli <joelja () bogus com>
Date: Mon, 02 Nov 2009 11:57:30 -0800
Jack Bates wrote:
Joel Jaeggli wrote:A standardized set means it can be cooked into documentation, training, and potentially even products.Communities (except the standardized well known ones) are extremely diverse. For those that support even more granular traffic engineering by limiting which of their peers your routes might be transiting, I believe there are 2 distinct methods of using communities. The nature of communities, and the different levels of support and traffic engineering capabilities makes it difficult for it to be standardized. It would take even longer for anyone to adopt such a standard due to the sheer volume of routers and customers who would have to adapt from long term established policies.
You're not going to get any argument from me about the diversity of implmentations or the needs arising out of network specific optimization. That said, our previous conclusion was also that we couldn't reasonably do this for a subset of them so I don't have to go very far to be convinced. That said standardization would likely make some features more accessible and therefore more likely to be used, I don't think traffic engineering is something I particularly want to encourage to excess but RTBH is a know that more people need access to quite frankly. joel
Jack Bates
Current thread:
- Re: Upstream BGP community support, (continued)
- Message not available
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Matthew Petach (Nov 01)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Steve Bertrand (Nov 01)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Randy Bush (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Richard A Steenbergen (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Andy B. (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Randy Bush (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Patrick W. Gilmore (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Randy Bush (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Steve Meuse (Nov 05)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Jack Bates (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Joel Jaeggli (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Jack Bates (Nov 02)
- RE: Upstream BGP community support Brian Dickson (Nov 02)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Steve Meuse (Nov 05)
- Re: Upstream BGP community support Jack Bates (Nov 05)