nanog mailing list archives
Re: Future of WiMax
From: joel jaeggli <joelja () bogus com>
Date: Fri, 18 Jun 2010 15:41:07 -0700
On 2010-06-18 10:49, Akyol, Bora A wrote:
This is not exactly true. With the 3G networks (GSM) you can get. 7.2-Mbps HSDPA (downstream) 5.8-Mbps HSUPA (upstream)
3gpp rel7 hsdpa/hsupa goes about 4 fold faster than that down and twice as fast up without having to resort to mimo.
whether any of these technologies can beat a recycled 802.11n phy with time division duplex in the mac layer as far as throughput goes is very much an open question.
most of what you'd consider really high throughput from lte systems comes a the expense of spectrum that is shared with a a lot of other devices so don't think for a second you're going to get 170Mb/s down and 80Mb/s up.
LTE speeds are much more comparable to Wimax. -----Original Message----- From: Holmes,David A [mailto:dholmes () mwdh2o com] Sent: Thursday, June 17, 2010 10:16 AM To: Seth Mattinen; nanOG list Subject: RE: Future of WiMax For business purposes such as fixed wireless access for small branch offices, it would seem that Wi-Max is superior to current GSM and CDMA proprietary networks in that the upload/download speeds are symmetric. It appears that GSM and CDMA networks are based on the asymmetric low upload bandwidth/high download bandwidth model, thus placing severe restrictions on business use for fixed locations.
Current thread:
- Future of WiMax Seth Mattinen (Jun 16)
- Re: Future of WiMax Rubens Kuhl (Jun 16)
- RE: Future of WiMax Murphy, Jay, DOH (Jun 16)
- RE: Future of WiMax Dennis Burgess (Jun 17)
- Re: Future of WiMax Bret Clark (Jun 17)
- RE: Future of WiMax Dennis Burgess (Jun 17)
- Re: Future of WiMax Jared Mauch (Jun 17)
- Re: Future of WiMax Rubens Kuhl (Jun 16)
- RE: Future of WiMax Holmes,David A (Jun 17)
- RE: Future of WiMax Akyol, Bora A (Jun 18)
- Re: Future of WiMax joel jaeggli (Jun 18)
- RE: Future of WiMax Akyol, Bora A (Jun 18)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: Future of WiMax Gregory Hicks (Jun 16)
- Re: Future of WiMax Curtis Maurand (Jun 16)
- Re: Future of WiMax J Wytt (Jun 30)
- Re: Future of WiMax Curtis Maurand (Jun 16)