nanog mailing list archives
RE: turning on comcast v6
From: Jamie Bowden <jamie () photon com>
Date: Fri, 20 Dec 2013 13:07:27 +0000
From: Lee Howard [mailto:Lee () asgard org] On 12/20/13 7:36 AM, "Jamie Bowden" <jamie () photon com> wrote:From: Owen DeLong [mailto:owen () delong com]
I'm almost afraid to ask about the phrase "add-default-route=yes" in the dhcp-client configuration. That seems wrong on the face of it since you should be getting your routing information from RA and not DHCP.
No, no, no, a thousand times no. I'm sure RA is great for small SOHO networks and for ISPs as a means to hand out resources, but in a corporate environment, we hate you. How many times do the IPv6 people have to hear that until DHCPv6 reaches feature parity with DCHPv4, IPv6 is dead to enterprise networks?
"Parity" isn't enough information; what features are missing? RA is part of IPv6, but you don't have to use SLAAC. I'd say it's the DHC people who need to hear it, not the IPv6 people, but YMMV.
I have a question. Why does DHCP hand out router, net mask, broadcast address, etc. in IPv4; why don't we all just use RIP and be done with it? You don't have to like how enterprise networks are built, but you better acknowledge that they are their own animal that have their own needs and drivers, and telling them that the way their networks are built are wrong and they need to change their whole architecture, separation of service, security model, etc. to fit your idea of perfection isn't winning friends. You are, however, influencing people. Perhaps not in the manner you intended. Jamie
Current thread:
- Re: turning on comcast v6, (continued)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Ryan Wilkins (Dec 12)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Steve Meuse (Dec 12)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Randy Bush (Dec 12)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 ML (Dec 19)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Christopher Morrow (Dec 19)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Owen DeLong (Dec 19)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Christopher Morrow (Dec 19)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Gary Buhrmaster (Dec 19)
- RE: turning on comcast v6 Jamie Bowden (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Lee Howard (Dec 20)
- RE: turning on comcast v6 Jamie Bowden (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Lee Howard (Dec 20)
- RE: turning on comcast v6 Matthew Huff (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Owen DeLong (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Matthew Huff (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Owen DeLong (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Christopher Morrow (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Mark Andrews (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Matthew Huff (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Owen DeLong (Dec 20)
- Re: turning on comcast v6 Matthew Huff (Dec 20)