nanog mailing list archives
Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G?
From: Owen DeLong via NANOG <nanog () nanog org>
Date: Fri, 24 Jun 2022 12:38:39 -0700
On Jun 24, 2022, at 12:33 , Michael Thomas <mike () mtcc com> wrote: On 6/24/22 9:09 AM, Chris Wright wrote:The term "5G" among technical circles started vague, became better defined over the course of several years, and is becoming vague again. This nuance was never well understood in the public eye, nor by mass publications like CNN. This is a battle for 12GHz, not 5G.But is what Starlink saying true or not? It would be a pity to not have an alternative to incumbent telephants. Mike
It’s not entirely clear, without knowing the technical details of the Starlink modulation scheme whether or not they could successfully share the 12Ghz spectrum. I have no reason to disbelieve their claims. Frankly, I really don’t think that Dish’s idea of providing 5G mobile service from satellites is a particularly good or beneficial one and granting them 12Ghz spectrum for this purpose is probably not really in the public interest. OTOH, I think Starlink is most definitely an interesting product that does provide a clear path to reasonable alternatives to the incumbent telephants. However, Dish isn’t exactly a traditional elephant, either. Owen
Current thread:
- What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Michael Thomas (Jun 23)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? William Herrin (Jun 23)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Eric Kuhnke (Jun 23)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? John Levine (Jun 23)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Nathan Stratton (Jun 24)
- RE: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Chris Wright (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Dave Taht (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? William Herrin (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Michael Thomas (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Owen DeLong via NANOG (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Joel Esler via NANOG (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? William Herrin (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Michael Thomas (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Owen DeLong via NANOG (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Mike Hammett (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Crist Clark (Jun 24)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? blakangel (Jun 25)
- RE: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? nanog () jima us (Jun 27)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Eric Kuhnke (Jun 27)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? Eric Kuhnke (Jun 23)
- Re: What say you, nanog re: Starlink vs 5G? William Herrin (Jun 23)