Penetration Testing mailing list archives
Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications)
From: Pete Herzog <lists () isecom org>
Date: Mon, 16 Jul 2007 20:46:15 +0200
Hi Ken,Unfortunately, skills-based certification is the closest thing that exists to what is really required, decent apprenticeships. While "virtual" apprenticeships happen through hacker groups and to some regards in certain on-line training venues, that doesn't come close to giving the well-rounded skills a professional security tester needs in the modern workplace.
I was lucky enough to have a great mentor during my time at IBM and what Peter Klee didn't teach me about just knowing how to be a "smart security consultant" as he called it could fit in a thimble. For a year that guy dragged me to analyst meetings and customer meetings and presentations and internal department meetings where I just sat there with my mouth shut and learned how security professionals handle themselves. That doesn't happen these days. Kids leave college with a few infosec courses under their belt and they become security professionals already assessing other people's business. There's no substitute for proper apprenticeship. But since that won't happen much anymore we need to find other ways to prove ourselves. We do that by showing it to an independent 3rd party to rate our ability to apply knowledge and skills to realistic problems in a timely manner. And that's what ISECOM is doing. It's the closest thing you can get to proving experience and ability like in an apprenticeship.
This whole thing about work experience voucher and all that is a sham that more and more people get around. That doesn't mean anything! We all work with people who share the same job title but not the same work ethic or skills. Yet after 2 years they are the same level as you according to these business experience certification requirements. It's so hokey that I even have to use the word "hokey" and that alone is upsetting! ;)
Sincerely, -pete. Ken Kousky wrote:
When exploring certification programs it's also important to note that ANSI/OSI have a standard for the certification of professional licensing and certification programs. The ANSI/OSI framework does not allow for this kindof approach, where you have to buy a specific training product or program.A professional licensing process should be an independent test of competencies and not a measure of the training program an individualpurchases.The DoD 8570 directive endorses ANSI/OSI certified certification programs - I think for this reason. It's not buying training but establishing competencies that matters. It's what you know, not what you buy. I think mostgood professionalcertifications are moving in this direction.We still have a long way to go before the processional standards for competency are clearly codified. Right now, the targeted skills continue to evolve with the exploits but we're starting to better understand the need for foundation skills and then specific applications of these skills.KWK
------------------------------------------------------------------------ This List Sponsored by: Cenzic Swap Out your SPI or Watchfire app sec solution for Cenzic's robust, accurate risk assessment and management solution FREE - limited Time Offer http://www.cenzic.com/c/wf-spi ------------------------------------------------------------------------
Current thread:
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications), (continued)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) ppsih (Jul 12)
- Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Pete Herzog (Jul 12)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Russell Butturini (Jul 13)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) ppsih (Jul 13)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Russell Butturini (Jul 13)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Panayiotis Psihoyios (Jul 13)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Ric Messier (Jul 13)
- Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications) ppsih (Jul 13)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Clement Dupuis (Jul 13)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Ken Kousky (Jul 15)
- Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Pete Herzog (Jul 16)
- Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Andrew Blyth (Jul 17)
- Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Jamie Riden (Jul 18)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Ken Kousky (Jul 17)
- Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Pete Herzog (Jul 23)
- Re: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Jamie Riden (Jul 13)
- Certifications Andrew Blyth (Jul 13)
- RE: Mile2 Training (Certifications) Alex Balayan (Jul 11)
- Re: Security Testing Certifications (was Mile2 Training (Certifications)) Pete Herzog (Jul 12)