RE: OWASP Top Ten - My Case For Updating It

[Jeff Robertson <Jeff.Robertson () DigitalInsight com>]

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Mark Curphey [mailto:mark () curphey com]
>
>
> If the problem of web application security is poor software 
> quality, it is a
> natural conclusion that the solution is to build better 
> software. Not once
> in the top ten does the list address the fact that the 
> majority of software
> is built without a design, security requirements or a 
> repeatable software
> security development process. 

I would go so far as to say that unless a development shop is already
following a process (I don't want to start waterfall vs. RUP vs. XP wars
here) to keep plain old functionality bugs down to a minimum, they have no
hope of producing secure software. 

If a software company haven't even figured out that their developers need to
be doing unit tests, then the idea that they could successfully implement
any sort of security testing is just putting the cart before the horse.