Re: Problem with SATAN/VMS

[newsham () aloha net (Timothy Newsham)]

> SATAN on AIX has a similar problem.
> AIX emits a permission denied that the simple test (test -s) doesn't catch
>
> > The bourne shell script 'rsh.satan' falsely reports a vulnerability on 
> > hosts that are running DEC VMS 6.1  This is because the OS sends the 
> > following message to standard output:
> >
> >     UCX$RSHD - Permission denied - host IP addr
> >
> > To fix, just add a test for the above string to the 'if $TEST -s 
> > "$tmp_file"' test in 'rsh.satan'.

The correct way to test for success or failure is obvious from the
following (from the rshd man page):

DIAGNOSTICS
     Except for the last one listed below, all diagnostic messages are re-
     turned on the initial socket, after which any network connections are
     closed.  An error is indicated by a leading byte with a value of 1 (0 is
     returned in step 9 above upon successful completion of all the steps pri-
     or to the execution of the login shell).

If an rshd does not do this I'd be inclined to call it broken.

> Andreas Siegert       afx () ibm de / afx () barolo ak munich ibm com / AFX at IPNET