nanog mailing list archives
BGP as an IGP (Was Re: IGPs in use)
From: Chrisy Luke <chrisy () flix net>
Date: Tue, 13 Oct 1998 18:16:53 +0100
Paul G. Donner wrote (on Oct 13):
If BGP rides on TCP, how are the TCP sessions built if BGP itself is used as the IGP?
Same way as it does when you take next-hops from any other IGP. The fact that one already has a route to ones' directly attached networks. When you speak to a router that is directly attached and has BGP speaking routers beyond it, it learns the networks of the interfaces attached to that router. It then knows how to reach the networks directly behind it, connects to the BGP speakers on those networks and so forth. If you can't speak to a BGP router, you time out and try again later, when perhaps you have learnt a route to it via other means. With OSPF it builds up this information at startup from it's neighbours, all of which keep a complete map of the network, all of which must be learnt, the only difference is the mechanism is more propogatative than discoverish. You can frig this of course by using BGP reflectors.
How does this affect the hierarchy of the network since all iBGP speakers must be fully meshed?
iBGP doesn't need to be fully meshed to work, even without reflection. The results are perfectly predictable. A machine that only needs to know internal routes doesn't need to speak to any transit routers, for instance. And in any case, the results are no worse than in the "my network died and is booting up slowly" situation when you're running any other IGP. It takes just as long for everything to converge. Chris. -- == chris () easynet net, chrisy () flix net, chrisy () flirble org == Systems Manager for Easynet, part of Easynet Group PLC.
Current thread:
- Re: IGPs in use, (continued)
- Re: IGPs in use Chrisy Luke (Oct 12)
- Re: IGPs in use Randy Bush (Oct 12)
- Re: IGPs in use David O'Leary (Oct 12)
- Re: IGPs in use Phillip Vandry (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use Jared Mauch (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use Alex Bligh (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use Tony Li (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use Chrisy Luke (Oct 12)
- Re: IGPs in use Ben Black (Oct 12)
- Re: IGPs in use Chrisy Luke (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use Paul G. Donner (Oct 13)
- BGP as an IGP (Was Re: IGPs in use) Chrisy Luke (Oct 13)
- RE: IGPs in use Thom Youngblood (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use bmanning (Oct 12)
- Re: IGPs in use Richard Irving (Oct 12)
- Re: IGPs in use Paul Ferguson (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use Howard C. Berkowitz (Oct 13)
- Re: IGPs in use Tony Li (Oct 13)
- Scaling Existing IGP Administration (was) Re: IGPs in use Howard C. Berkowitz (Oct 14)
- Re: IGPs in use Henk Smit (Oct 14)