nanog mailing list archives
Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd)
From: Jared Mauch <jared () puck Nether net>
Date: Tue, 9 Oct 2001 12:37:06 -0400
On Tue, Oct 09, 2001 at 12:27:55PM -0400, Christopher A. Woodfield wrote:
As it turns out, both 2008 and 3300 are Infonet, US and Europe. So this was their foo. The problem is obviously that the RFC-proscribed behavior with bad prefixes works on paper, as it serves to isolate the network originating the problem prefix. However, that is totally dependent on /every/ router doing so, thus preventing the problem from spreading, which as we discovered, does not happen. The ideal alternative behavior is to drop the bad prefix--not dropping the peer, but not passing the bad prefix along either. I've been told that there are recent Cisco IOS revs that do this instead of passing it along, but they have other unresolved bugs that prevent their widespread use. Should someone think about possibly updating the RFC?
you are stuck in the situation that operators are faced in deciding what software to run on their network. if the internet-draft is updated you still need vendors to change their behavior and people to upgrade. - jared
Current thread:
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) jlewis (Oct 07)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Randy Bush (Oct 08)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Christopher A. Woodfield (Oct 08)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) abha (Oct 08)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Rafi Sadowsky (Oct 09)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Christopher A. Woodfield (Oct 09)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Christopher A. Woodfield (Oct 09)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Jared Mauch (Oct 09)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Sean Donelan (Oct 09)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Christopher A. Woodfield (Oct 09)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Randy Bush (Oct 09)
- RE: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Matt Levine (Oct 09)
- RE: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Robert Boyle (Oct 09)
- RE: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) (DUH!) Robert Boyle (Oct 09)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Christopher A. Woodfield (Oct 08)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Randy Bush (Oct 08)
- Re: BGP noise tonight? (fwd) Joel Baker (Oct 09)